REVIEW: Beneath a Midnight Moon by Catherine Cowles

Posted November 16th, 2026 by in Blog, Contemporary Romance, HJ Top Pick!, Review / 0 comments

HJ_TopPick

In Beneath a Midnight Moon by Catherine Cowles, Being a therapist, Aster Carrington knows there are events from her past that still should be dealt with and conversations that can’t be avoided forever. Case in point: Maverick “Mav” Archer, aka Satan, as she likes to call him. His family’s property borders Moonridge Meadow Ranch, her grandfather’s pride and joy. And from the time Mav and his brothers moved in with their uncle almost twenty years ago, Aster has been part of their world. But everything changed between her and Mav on graduation night. She’s spent years pushing her feelings for the firefighter aside, barely acknowledging his presence. Yet somehow when Aster’s past comes roaring back into her life with a family tragedy, it’s Mav who comes to her rescue–by offering to marry her. If it means she can keep the ranch safe, the one constant in her life, then how can she refuse?

“Aster, you do know Mav has his arm around you, right? Blink twice if he brainwashed you.”
Maverick scowled at her. “That’s rude, Supernova. And honestly, I’m surprised you’re shocked. It’s pretty normal for fiancés to show a little PDA.”
“Fiancés?” she squeaked. Her gaze dropped to my left hand and the massive diamond on my ring finger. “But you hate him.”
“That was just foreplay. Right, Kitten?”
I stomped on his foot with my heel as I pasted on an adoring expression. “You know it, Pookie Pie.”

Mav always had a bit of a wild streak growing up but it wasn’t until Aster ghosted him after graduation that he became an adrenaline junkie. From his job as a firefighter and hotspot jumper to every extreme outdoor sport known to man, he’s constantly riding a razor’s edge. Most of the time it helps keep the darkness of his family’s past at bay as well. But when Mav shows up unexpectedly at Moonridge Meadow to find not only Aster but also the property in jeopardy, he tries to act fast. A marriage proposal was probably not the wisest choice. Although the look on his former best friend’s face was priceless. Mav can only hope they’ll be able to work together to save the ranch. And possibly have a chance to find out exactly why Aster disappeared years ago–maybe even rekindle the feelings that are still simmering just under the surface as well.

‘Fuck only friendship. I was on a one-man mission to seduce my wife.’

Completely addictive. That’s really the only way to describe BENEATH A MIDNIGHT MOON. It’s the type of story where I couldn’t get enough of the characters, but it was also constantly on my mind when I wasn’t reading. It was that immersive and compelling. At this point, though, I would expect nothing less from Catherine Cowles.

“You were a constellation of stars, lighting my path when I was living in the dark.”

I’m honestly not sure where to start with book three in the Starlight Grove series because WOW. Cowles’ self-dubbed “murdery romances” are some of my favorite contemporary books for a number of reasons but the top two were shining bright here: the multi-faceted characters and the thrillingly high-paced plots. I swear I spend most of my time convinced that nearly every cast member could be the bad guy–until the reveal (or reveals, plural, in this case…) knocks me sideways. Piecing it all together is enormously fun. But in Maverick and Aster’s story, it was their shared history, the past trauma they overcame, their slow burn romance, and their family sagas that made this so special.

TROPES/VIBES:
🔍 Romantic suspense
⚔️ Former friends to enemies to lovers
💍 Marriage of convenience
🔥 Fiery banter
🫂 Hurt/comfort
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Family sagas
😂 Humor & heat

CW: View Spoiler »

Aster and Mav’s frenemy vibe has been woven throughout the first two books in the series so to get a true feel for their incredibly complicated history, I would highly suggest reading from the beginning.

They were best friends from the time Mav and his brothers moved to Starlight Grove nearly two decades ago. But no one ever knew why Aster left town–or why she and Mav have been at odds ever since. The truth finally did come out late in the book. And yikes was there a reason for her to have run! The events that happened the night of their high school graduation had lasting effects on Aster and Mav’s current lives so when they actually communicated, realizing the time they missed out on together, it was bittersweet. But it led to much healing and a chance to start over in their own way.

The suspense portion was on point as always. There were multiple people who were not necessarily evil–some definitely were–but they were more of a morally gray type. And I loved trying to figure out how everything was connected. Cowles certainly isn’t afraid to put her characters through their paces, Mav and Aster being a prime example. But through all of the danger, it showed how close of a bond they shared as well as how many people loved them and had their backs. Namely, the Archer family. The Starlight Grove community also stepped up, making for a lot of cozy, heartwarming scenes that will work their way into readers’ hearts, I’m sure.

If you’re a fan of hard-won HEAs and epic epilogues with teasers but no spoilers then BENEATH A MIDNIGHT MOON would be a great addition to your autumn TBR.

QOTD: What was the last book you couldn’t stop thinking about after you finished reading it?

Book Info:

Publication: Published: November 17th, 2026 | by Evermore | Starlight Grove #3

He’s spent years trying to outrun his tortured past. She’ll do anything to forget all he was to her. But one reckless plea will change everything for good… Marry me.

Aster Carrington wasn’t sure she’d ever return to Starlight Grove—the town that broke her trust and destroyed everything she once believed in. But when her grandfather needed help on the ranch, the therapist known for helping others heal had no choice but to face the ghosts she had buried long ago. What she never expected was the man she once loved to be waiting in the shadows for all these years…and that marrying him might be the only thing to keep her and her beloved ranch safe.

Maverick Archer has built a life in the flames: smokejumper, firefighter, adrenaline junkie—anything to outrun the shadows of his family’s violent legacy and the grief of losing the only girl he’s ever loved. But when Aster surges back into his life, the fire he’s fought to snuff out roars back to flame. Only this time, the danger isn’t just in his blood. It’s coming for her.

As long-buried secrets surface and a killer’s obsession threatens to destroy everything they’ve rebuilt, Aster and Mav must decide if some scars are reminders of survival or warnings of a past that refuses to stay buried.

 

add-goodreads

Please leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.